The Reflective Teacher

rethinking education

Main menu

Skip to content
  • Home

Search

Tag Archives: teacher appraisal

April 4, 2013

What SHOULD Engagement Look Like?

20130404-060940.jpg

I’ve been thinking a lot about student engagement and what it should look like in the classroom. I recently had my formal observation and saw that I received high marks for student engagement but mid-marks for critical thinking. This got me thinking: if students weren’t engaged in critical thinking then what WERE they engaged in? What factors did my Principal consider to determine that my students were “fully” engaged? I started exploring the dictionary for a definition first. The dictionary states:


engage-definition

So, in a nutshell, engagement means the act of DOING something or something that holds your attention. In other words, if my students are busy doing something educational or are paying attention and remaining on-task, then they are “engaged” in the lesson. This is easy enough to do as a teacher, but it’s not how I want my Principal to view my classroom. I don’t believe that engagement is the same as “attentive” or “on-task.” I don’t believe that a teacher should get high marks for student engagement without also receiving high marks for critical thinking. My definition of engagement looks more like this (taken from Wikipedia):

Student engagement occurs when “students make a psychological investment in learning. They try hard to learn what school offers. They take pride not simply in earning the formal indicators of success (grades), but in understanding the material and incorporating or internalizing it in their lives.”[1]

In looking at this definition, I’m not so sure that student engagement can be gleaned from a single walk through or formal observation. True engagement has to be observed over time. So what does this look like in the classroom? We need to see students questioning, creating, exploring, and defining learning objectives. Simply sitting at their desks “doing” something is called “playing school” and I think a lot of teachers and students become really good at that, especially when Principals are giving high marks for such behavior. We need to re-think how we engage students and how we evaluate that engagement. Simply handing a student a worksheet and having them sit quietly working on it does not mean they are engaged in their learning. Even “fun” PBL assignments don’t necessarily bring about student engagement. Students laughing at your jokes and enjoying the classroom environment also does not directly define engagement. Ultimately the product students create will be the biggest indicator of their engagement.

In my opinion, critical thinking and engagement go hand in hand. We want students to invest themselves, own their learning, and internalize valuable skills in order to apply them to a variety of situations. We don’t want them to simply be “on-task” or “attentive.” While I think the teacher should be evaluated on student participation (keeping a class on-task and attentive throughout a 90-minute course is no small feat); however, we need to label this something other than “engagement”.

What are your thoughts on student engagement? What should it look like?

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr

Like this:

Like Loading...
  • Posted in musings
  • Tagged formal observation, learning, PDAS, principal feedback, student engagement, teacher appraisal
  • 2 Comments

Post navigation

Recent Musings

  • The Nuance of Vocabulary Instruction
  • What are you doing for others?
  • How You Play the Game

The Author

headshot taken by my awesome husband, Michael Samaripa; Copyright 2007--Inner Light Creations

Twitter Updates

  • RT @realcaunsia: Andrea Hall is Georgia Captain Firefighter, she’s coda as well! She’s amazing and I love how she representing us! 💕 CODAs… 4 days ago
  • RT @KatBrockway: See a statement from Georgia School for the Deaf Alumni Association in honor of Andrea Hall, a CODA. (Source: GSDAA Facebo… 4 days ago
  • RT @HabenGirma: When identifying race in visual descriptions for #blind people, don't skip white. Often I read things like: John, a Black m… 1 week ago
  • RT @MonroePedagogy: For now on, I mark #TJDeafEd to focus on social change(issues) in #deafed. Believe openness and transparency create pos… 1 week ago
  • RT @LaurenMaucere: Please tune in and learn more about what is going on in #DeafEd. A statewide organization @CaledOrg was recently banned… 1 week ago
Follow @tcsamaripa

Blogs I Follow

  •  Zoom Video
  • : the readiness is all
  • What Price Bananas?
  • Nourishing Genius
  • Diane Ravitch's blog
  • The Learning Principal
  • Game4Learning
  • FlippedMind
  • TMI Flips English - Blog: Ion Lucidity
  • The Tech Classroom
  • harga obat herbal ejakulasi dini
  • Silvia Tolisano- Langwitches Blog
  • TechChef
  • Tech & Learning
  • Technology and the Common Core
  • Free Technology for Teachers
  • EdTech Chic
  • Deaf Characters in Adolescent Literature

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 712 other followers

    teacher login

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.com

    RSS Grammar Girl Quick & Dirty Tips

    • 807 - Why We Call Them Sea 'Shanties.' A Trick to Remember How to Spell 'Conscience' January 21, 2021
      If you're enjoying sea shanties these days, have you wondered why they're called "shanties"? Plus, I always have a hard time remembering how to spell "conscience." Here's my trick for getting it right. Subscribe to the newsletter for regular updates.  Watch my LinkedIn Learning writing course. Join the conversation on Faceb […]
    • 806 - Why You Should Try Fanfiction. How to Find Tricky Pronunciations. January 14, 2021
      Why writing fanfiction can make you a better overall writer. Plus, my tricks for figuring out tricky pronunciations. Subscribe to the newsletter for regular updates.  Watch my LinkedIn Learning writing course. Join the conversation on Facebook and Twitter. Grammar Pop iOS game. Peeve Wars card game. Grammar Girl books. HOST: Mignon Fogarty VOICEMAIL: 833-214 […]
    • 805 - 'Acedia': the lost name for the emotion we're all feeling right now January 7, 2021
      "Acedia": the lost name for the emotion we're all feeling right now. Plus, when does "thank you" need a hyphen? Subscribe to the newsletter for regular updates.  Watch my LinkedIn Learning writing course. Join the conversation on Facebook and Twitter. Grammar Pop iOS game. Peeve Wars card game. Grammar Girl books. HOST: Mignon Fogart […]

    Tag Cloud

    #flipclass #SBGchat 21st century Academic ASL Academic Conversations administration American Sign Language authentic writers back to basics BICS/CALP BIG BANG black history month blended learning blogging burn out connecting with students content-based instruction Critical thinking Cummins deaf history month deaf pride digital citizenship digital writing Disability edmodo Education english Facebook failure fear finding balance flipped classroom flipped learning flipping flow formal observation grades Hamlet hard work Hearing impairment homework Jeff Zweirs kidblog Kidblog.org learning literacy multicultural students PDAS persuasive speeches praise principal feedback principals prioritizing professional development project-based learning project based sage-on-the-stage self-paced Shakespeare standards-based grading starting out student-centered student-centered instruction student engagement Teacher teacher appraisal teacher duties teacher struggles teaching Technology twitter versoapp writing
Blog at WordPress.com.
 Zoom Video

: the readiness is all

If everyone is thinking alike, then somebody isn't thinking.

What Price Bananas?

rethinking education

Nourishing Genius

Learn organically, change the world.

Diane Ravitch's blog

A site to discuss better education for all

The Learning Principal

Moving Forward... most of the time

Game4Learning

Fun Learning Resouces for Kids

FlippedMind

The Flipped Classroom as a Student-Centered State of Mind

TMI Flips English - Blog: Ion Lucidity

rethinking education

The Tech Classroom

Just another WordPress.com site

harga obat herbal ejakulasi dini

rethinking education

Silvia Tolisano- Langwitches Blog

The Magic of Learning

TechChef

rethinking education

Tech & Learning

rethinking education

Technology and the Common Core

rethinking education

Free Technology for Teachers

rethinking education

EdTech Chic

rethinking education

Deaf Characters in Adolescent Literature

rethinking education

Cancel
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
%d bloggers like this: